
Choose a social media agency by checking four things: proven results with brands like yours, a clear strategy process before content starts, knowing exactly who will do the work, and reporting tied to business goals like inquiries or bookings. Ask for case studies with numbers and timeframes, and be wary of guaranteed follower counts or long contracts with no exit.
What should you look for first?
Results with brands like yours. A hotel should see hospitality results; a brokerage should see real estate results. Ask for case studies with specific numbers and a timeframe, like "84% more Reel shares," not just "increased engagement."
10 questions to ask before you hire
Can you show results from a business like mine, with numbers and timeframes?
Who will actually work on my account?
A senior strategist, a junior coordinator or a subcontractor?
What happens before the first post?
Look for an audit, positioning and a written plan.
Who creates the photos and video?
In-house, freelancers, or me?
How many posts and platforms are included, and what costs extra?
How do you handle comments and DMs, and how fast?
What will you report on each month?
Inquiries, bookings and leads, or just likes?
Is ad spend included?
(It almost never is.)
What's the contract length, and how do I leave?
Who owns the content and accounts if we part ways?
What are the red flags?
- Guaranteed follower numbers or "viral" results
- No written strategy, just a posting package
- Reports that show only reach, likes and followers
- You can't find out who does the work
- Long contracts with no performance review point
- They ask for ownership of your accounts or content
How do you compare proposals fairly?
- Scope: posts per month, platforms, video, community management
- Strategy: audit and written plan before content starts
- Team: named strategist; who creates the content
- Reporting: monthly, tied to inquiries or sales
- Terms: contract length, exit terms, content ownership
- Price: monthly fee, add-ons, ad spend separate
Should you choose a local San Diego agency?
Local matters most if you need on-site photo and video. A San Diego agency can shoot at your property, clinic or listings without travel costs. For strategy and posting alone, location matters less than results and fit.
What should happen in the first 90 days?
- Month 1: strategy, content calendar, first posts live.
- Month 2: consistent posting, first performance report, adjustments.
- Month 3: clear trends in reach and engagement; early signs of inquiries.
- If you're 90 days in with no plan, no reports and no visible improvement, it's fair to ask hard questions.
FAQ
How long should I give a social media agency to show results?+
Give it about 90 days to see clear trends; inquiries and sales typically build after a consistent quarter.
Should I sign a long contract?+
Many agencies ask for an initial 3–6 months. Make sure there's a review point and a clear exit.
Do I own my content if I leave?+
You should. Confirm in writing that your accounts and the content made for you stay yours.
What should happen on a first call?+
A good agency asks about your goals, looks at your current social with you, and gives you a few honest quick wins before talking price.
Want help with your social?
Book a 15-minute call. We'll show you three quick wins, whether or not we work together.
Book a call

